Nursing home deaths: When to suspect something isn’t quite right

Some nursing homes try to offer their residents good personal and medical care, but these reputable facilities are often overshadowed by the lack of care given at many other homes. Nursing homes are notorious for not providing patients with the care that they need in order to live a full and happy life. An injury lawyer understands that in many instances, elderly patients within these homes are neglected, abused, and even killed by those who have sworn to protect and care for them.

(article continues below infographic)
MS04_-July_Ankin-3_Nursing-Home-Deaths Nursing home deaths: When to suspect something isn't quite right

When a family has no choice but to place their elderly loved one in a home, it is often difficult to determine whether or not the workers of the nursing home they have chosen are genuinely concerned for the welfare of their residents. Unfortunately, it often takes some time to fully see the truth. In that time, patients may die, leaving families unsure of what happened or where to turn.

A problem with the system

Many of these nursing home deaths are labeled the simple, natural result of old age or other ailments common to those in the elderly population. According to pbs.org, the truth is that few nursing home deaths are investigated. This is due to the nature of how deaths are ruled suspicious. In most cases, the physicians treating patients are the ones who determine whether or not they died under natural circumstances. If the doctor sees a fatality that may be suspicious, he is required to report it to the medical examiner or coroner for further investigation.

The problem arises because doctors often get it wrong. PBS reports that a 2008 study found that nearly half of all doctors who participated failed to correctly identify the cause of death for an elderly patient who had suffered a brain injury due to a fall. Unfortunately, an injury lawyer knows that falls are a contributing factor in many nursing home patient deaths.

An additional problem arises when doctors are not even required to see the body of the deceased before they rule their deaths natural or suspicious, as is allowed in most states. In one shocking example reported by PBS, an 83-year-old patient was beaten to death by an aide, yet the doctor simply marked the death unsuspicious because he never saw the bruises caused by the beating.

A widespread issue

The National Center on Elder Abuse reports that instances of elder abuse and neglect are so widespread that we have no true way to know for certain how many people are affected by it every year. One study found that only one in 14 cases is ever reported. Another study, the New York Elder Abuse Prevalence Study found that the number is closer to one in 24 cases.

Abuse in nursing homes happens at unacceptable levels. The NCEA reports that 44 percent of nursing home residents who participated in a survey indicated that they had been personally abused while 95 percent indicated that they had witnessed another patient being neglected.

Those who are being abused are more likely to be killed in these neglectful or hostile situations. Just like other forms of abuse, it often escalates until the abuser causes significant enough injuries to cause death. For the elderly who are confined to nursing homes, even one episode of abuse can be fatal.

It could happen to anyone

Unfortunately, these horrors often occur in Illinois. A South Holland, Illinois nurse is a suspect in the deaths of three elderly patients who were under her care. According to WGNTV.com, six patients at a nursing home were hospitalized recently for unknown causes. One of the patients, a 98-year-old woman, died the day after she and the other patients were admitted. Another two residents died shortly thereafter.

The Cook County medical examiner’s office has determined that the elderly woman died after being administered toxic levels of potent painkillers, morphine and hydrocodone. She also suffered from two serious heart conditions, which contributed to her death. This has prompted police to investigate the other two deaths as potential homicides as well. The nurse who was caring for all six individuals has been suspended, but has yet to be charged in the matter.

When a nursing home death occurs

After losing an elderly loved one, it is never easy. Things are made even worse when the death seems suspicious. Those who have lost loved ones in a nursing home should always follow their instincts. If they feel that something is not right, they should take the time to determine whether or not foul play was involved. Family members should ask the following questions:

  • Did the doctor see the body before filling out the death certificate?
  • Were there any unexplained bruises on the body?
  • How do staff treat current patients?
  • How clean and well-kept is the facility?
  • Was the deceased malnourished or dehydrated?
  • What medications was the patient seeing before he or she died?

While these questions do not guarantee that family members will immediately discover the truth, it will help the facility in question know that the family will not easily give up without an investigation. In some cases, the facility may become uncooperative or unhelpful. This should be a red flag that something is amiss and family members should then proceed with asking law enforcement or other state agencies to become involved and perform an investigation.

Those who have lost loved ones to suspicious nursing home deaths may have grounds for a case against the home, its administrators and the individuals who were deemed responsible for the deaths. Affected parties should contact an Illinois injury lawyer immediately for a case review.

Memberships
& Awards

Leading lawyers BBB super lawyers the chicago bar association Illinois trial lawyers Association workers compensation lawyers association
footer-img

Our Location

Ankin Law Office LLC
10 N Dearborn, Suite 500 Chicago, Illinois 60602
Toll Free: 844-600-0000
Local: 312-600-0000 Full-Sized Map & Directions

Helping clients in the following areas:Our firm handles workers' compensation and personal injury claims in Chicago, Berwyn, Joliet, Cicero, Waukegan, Chicago Heights, Elgin, Oak Park, Oak Lawn, Schaumburg, Bolingbrook, Glendale Heights, Aurora, Niles, Schaumburg, Arlington Heights, Naperville, Plainfield and all of Cook, DuPage, Lake, Will, McHenry, LaSalle, Kankakee, McLean and Peoria Counties.

Information For Lawyers
single.php